Joaquin Melgarejo 10th
In what ways does Major use rhetoric
in his speech and what impact does this have on the animals?
Major uses
rhetoric in his speech in a number of ways. His aim is to make the animals
conscious of their situation and to convince them to overthrow humans. He uses
tricolon, rhetorical questions and contrast to persuade the animals of his
utopian vision.
During the
speech, Old Major uses tricolon because his purpose is to prove by giving
examples, that the real enemy is mankind and to make the animals realize about
the gravity of their situation, as well as convincing them with his ideology. “Our
lives are miserable, laborious and short”p3. As we can observe in this
quotation, Major is saying the truth and the reality of the animals` life in
the farm which is hard and this shows the animals many conditions about the way
they are living. The use of tricolon is to support the fact that they are not
living an ideal animal life.
Old major
uses rethorical questions in his speech because he wants the animals to reflect
about their actual life conditions and to make them think about how is their
true nature. “What is the nature of this life of ours?”p3 As we can see, Major
is giving a particular thoughtful question because he wants the animals think
about if their actual nature which they are living is correct, if it is the
right one, to be human dependent animals. The use of this device is to persuade
and mainly, to make the animals reflect.
Contrast is
used by Major in his speech to describe and explain the differences between the
farm animals and people in order to convince the animals. “Man serves the
interests of no creature except himself. And among us animals let there be
perfect unity, perfect comradeship in the struggle.” p6. This quotation tells
us the main difference between those entities, human does not care about the
animals, while animals are united and caring and also share the same concerns.
The use of contrast is to define the differences between entities so animals
can see and reflect about the real issue.
In conclusion,
rhetoric, the art or ability of speaking and writing effectively with
persuasion as a support to the arguments, is found in Majors` speech by giving
accurate examples of their lives, by making the animals reflect deeply and by
telling the differences between them and their enemies.
No hay comentarios:
Publicar un comentario